Taxonomy and Local Search

Kelsey references a piece from the head of BD at Localeze talking about Taxonomy and IYPs/Local sites. The gist of it is, we need to be designing these sites to be more than just category and geography driven and make them more focused around a search-based structure, where users can really search for what they need and not have to try to figure out what category to look for. This really gets back to that discussion that the last generation focused on browse by category and this generation is all about search.

Kelsey Group Blogs

Verticals in the Local Space

A "consultant specializing in vertical development" talks about how the local space has been slow to really build out Vertical sites, focusing on areas like auto, wedding, legal, etc. This is definitely a direction local sites need to go in, and the first site that gets to become a one-stop-shop, with solid content in all the major verticals, along with their core business listings, should gain good traction with users as their default local site. And the good news for all of us who aren't Google is that this is not the kind of thing they do, so the door is open for someone else to step through.

Kelsey Group Blogs » Vertical Slowdown? Teresa Lawlor Discusses Challenges

IYP Reach in the US (according to Google)

Via TechSoapBox:



IYP Reach in the US (according to Google) - Tech Soapbox

Medical Categories Slowly Moving Online

For traditional yellow pages companies, Doctors, Dentists and related categories are huge revenue generators. Online, though, they've been very slow to adopt (as with Real Estate, which we discussed yesterday). Several companies have tried different approaches to bring these categories online, like HealthGrades and several competitors, which offer reviews of medical professionals. Looks like there's another new site moving into this space, called ZocDoc, which has information on doctors, the insurance they accept and allows you to schedule appointments. Like many Local startups, I suspect this one is going to run into a Sales issue, with doctors being very busy people and their front offices not really being equipped to spend their marketing money. Like all categories, this one will eventually be fully engaged online, but for the time being, I think the YPs, IYPs and Google will be the primary resources they'll use.

ZocDoc Gets $3M to Help You Find a Doctor

Optimizing Google OneBox and Yahoo! Shortcut Local Listings

Good article talking about how to best optimize your business listings to get good Google and Yahoo! local placements.

Optimizing Google OneBox and Yahoo! Shortcut Local Listings

Barrons Promotes RH Donnelly as "Risky, But Attractive"

RHD's stock is up 14% at the moment based mostly on an article in Barron's which indicates that, despite the 97% drop in stock price in the last year, RHD's directories are still experiencing strong usage in some sectors and are "far from dead". The albatross, as they say, is the $9.7B of net debt the companies holds. But, as they say, if you're looking for a high-risk, potential high-return stock, RHD may be one to check out. This article made me wonder if they feel the same about Idearc, but they didn't really say here.

Flashing Yellow, With Lots of Green - Barrons.com

Zillow Launches Mobile Search for Real Estate

Certain categories have seen good mobile/iPhone applications developed and others have not. I would put Real Estate in the latter category. Real Estate as an industry is known as a late adopter of technology, and apparently the mobile space is no different. Zillow, however, has launched a web application (not downloadable) allowing users to search for properties by street address, city, state or zip. I haven't been able to try it out yet, but it sounds good.

It is surprising that none of the larger real estate sites had an application ready at the launch of iPhone apps because of the natural fit of RE for the mobile space. It's natural to be out taking a walk, see a For Sale sign and want to know the price/bedroom/bath/etc. Or to be able to find open houses near your location.

While Zillow is getting a start, there are limitations to a web app which would be overcome with a downloadable iPhone app (which I'm sure Zillow is working on). The ability to easily save properties to your phone is one, but the bigger one is the ability to tap into the GPS/location-aware features of your phone to reduce the need to type in an address. As I've said, I'm sure it's coming, but hopefully it'll be here soon.

Touch-Tap-Click-Push…Search Properties From Your Mobile Browser | Zillow® Blog

User-Generated Reviews and Their Impact on Local

We talked about reviews and the ability for businesses to respond to them last week. Today on Valleywag, there was some discussion of a company possibly offering to push negative reviews to the bottom if businesses bought a paid ad with them (I'm not mentioning the company's name here, because Valleywag thinks this was just a rogue salesperson, not a real policy of that company).

However, this brings up some of the complexities of reviews and serving two masters: users and businesses. For users to really find the reviews content useful, it has to be real information that cannot be "bought" by businesses. Of course, if this is the case and a business already has significant numbers of negative reviews on a given site, it will make it more difficult to sell paid products to that business.

On the other side of the coin, there have been stories about consumers/users threatening businesses with negative reviews if they don't get what they want (which many times includes them demanding free product or the like). This is the downside of user generated reviews. While they give users the ability to provide information to others, there will always be some that abuse them.

So how can businesses solve this problem? To me, the answer is twofold:

1. Do the best you can to keep your customers happy. This may seem simple, but if you want good reviews, provide good service.
2. Promote your customers' involvement on the sites where you advertise (and for sites, this means give businesses the means to promote you on-site). Put up stickers in your window letting consumers know where to post reviews. Tell your staff to promote this (especially to happy customers). Happy customers will go out of their way to send you more business, but you need to give them the means to do so.

Finally, as we talked about last week, it is important that sites provide businesses with the means to respond to negative reviews and even challenge their validity from time to time. The purer the review system the better, but as local Internet companies, we always have to balance the needs of all of our constitutents.

Commentards: Yelp protection racket alleged by anonymous cowards

Yahoo Launches Fire Eagle

Yahoo's advanced research division, called Brickhouse, has released a highly anticipated platform called Fire Eagle. This platform allows developers to receive geo-location data from their users to easily integrate into their sites.

As GPS-enabled devices like the iPhone continue to proliferate and users start to see more value in providing their locations to websites, in order to get customized results, see who's nearby, etc, platforms like this will be key. This will allow the web to do some of its transition from a "pull" platform (ask for what you want and it will be shown to you) to a "push" platform (it will show you things you will be interested in without having to ask for them).

Yahoo Fire Eagle Launches Geo-Location Platform To The Public

iPhone Food Apps

Mashable has a writeup of 21 iPhone food apps, most of which are restaurant finders and reviews. Their review of the YPMobile App? "When worse comes to worse, hit up the Yellow Pages". They also had some good apps I haven't heard of, like one that includes the menus of many popular restaurants. A good read if you're looking for new apps for your iPhone or just want to see what your competitors are doing.

21 iPhone Food Apps to Eat Your Heart Out

Local-20 - Review and Analysis of Local 2.0 Sites

A new blog has launched which is doing analysis of Local 2.0 sites from around the world. Could be a great place to do some competitive research or pick up some best practices from sites you wouldn't otherwise see.

Local-20

Advertiser feedback on negative reviews

Today, Greg Sterling asks if the ability for advertisers to provide feedback on negative reviews is the future of reviews. I tend to agree with him that it's the future of online reviews, but it's also the past of reviews. Why do I say that? Because this is what eBay has been doing for years. As we all know, feedback is the key to the success of eBay's marketplace. Without trust in the buyer/seller you're dealing with, their system will not work.

However, as with local sites, one negative review can really impact your business on eBay, so they needed ways to deal with that negative feedback. The first thing they do is that they have the ability for users (sellers especially) to dispute negative feedback, although this ability is used sparingly. The ability for the seller to respond to negative feedback is really the main tool they have to keey their rating solid.

As IYPs and other local sites prepare for the next stage in their evolution, content is going to be critical, and reviews are a big part of that content. Local sites implementing reviews need to make sure they're not just slapped into the site, but that they are built with thought behind them, processes to support them, and the ability to get the advertisers involved and engaged. As we've seen from Merchant Circle's infamous launch strategy, negative feedback on a website is always a strong impetus for advertisers to get involved.

Is This the Future of Online Reviews? « Screenwerk

Should consumers be able to opt out of phone book deliveries?

Don't know how I missed this yesterday and is was on one of my favorite blogs, The Consumerist. It discusses attempts by some local governments to allow their residents to opt out of receiving phone books and the difficulties that previous governments have had in passing such laws.

It really seems like allowing people to opt out shouldnt negatively impact business much if advertisers are looking at their ads based on performance instead of on circulation. In fact, it could reduce costs for yellow pages companies (though it would require them to keep a database of who has opted in/out). However, there may be more impact than we would think.

Are there a lot of people who would opt out but end up keeping the phone books they are delivered and using them? I have heard the argument that phone books have the benefit of being able to find things faster than you can online and perhaps, if a pipe has burst or you have to do something really quickly, where you aren't familiar with a vendor, people still grab for Old Faithful. In any case, if you look at the comments on this article (which is read by some of the more tech-savvy people around) there is still a fair amount of support for the books, and people still see value in them.

Phone Books: Should Consumers Be Able To Opt-Out Of Phone Book Deliveries?

Self-Storage Reports Strong Profits

This one may be a bit off-topic, but relevant. As we move forward on this blog, we are going to talk a bit more about big local (Print, IYP and Search) categories, as it is relevant.

Storage and Moving and two big categories for us, and they're categories that are undergoing some growth right now, if this story is any indication. In this case, Public Storage has had their profits increase by 500% this quarter (vs last year), mostly due to the housing market. Realtors and Loans are two other big categories for the local space, and ones that are undergoing drastic shifts with the changes in the housing markets. We can probably all look for their investments in advertising to decrease a bit (at least temporarily). However, it looks like storage (and likely moving as well) may pick up some of the slack. Time for local sites to shift focus a bit?

Amid 91201 Foreclosures, Public Storage Inc. Reports Strong Gains | Redfin Los Angeles Sweet Digs

How Google Ranks Local Businesses

Here's a really informative paper on how Google ranks local businesses for their maps site (and I'd assume for other local searches as well).

Local Search Ranking Factors « Screenwerk

Why are hotels eliminating Yellow Pages

The Kelsey Group blog today has an interesting post about yellow pages in hotels. Some of the major chains, Hyatt, Omni and a few others, are discontinuing providing yellow pages in hotels. Seems a strange move, since people in a hotel are usually in an unfamiliar town and need to look up business information. But, the Kelsey blog thinks this is actually a move to get more people signing up to pay for the in-room Internet connection. Makes sense to me. That being said, I think hotel guests are probably a big enough traffic source for print YP usage to make it worthwhile for the YP companies to compenate the hotels to carry the books. That way, the hotels get their monetization either way...

Kelsey Group Blogs

MerchantCircle Launches Website Creation/Hosting

MerchantCircle has a new templated Website Creation product, which they're using to hook advertisers more deeply and offer a broader product set for those SMBs who don't have their own sites. Interesting quote for me here is that their next step is to move from impressions and clicks to calls. Seems a common theme that most local sites are moving to promoting calls as their key metric.

Kelsey Group Blogs » Merchant Circle Launches Web Site Creation/Hosting

Local Shopping on a Mobile Phone and What It Means

One area where there have been relatively few iPhone apps that have launched is the Shopping space. TheFind just launched what I believe to be the first shopping app, and while it's still in private Beta (which means I haven't gotten to test it yet), it got me thinking about what shopping on your phone will be about.

I'm sure sites like Amazon and others will have nice little apps you can use to buy products that are available on their websites (basically just extensions of their sites), but I think the real impact of these kinds of applications will be on brick and mortar prices. When shoppers go into stores and see prices now, they often don't have any basis for comparison (although many do check the price online before they go into the store). Some stores have kiosks in the store where you can browse their inventory, but a few (Best Buy comes to mind) have a different website for in-store purchases which may have prices that are different from their websites.

That's where mobile shopping could be really powerful. As a consumer, you can now enter a store with a mobile device that will show you prices for an item from all retailers. You will now have immediate transparency to whether you are getting a good deal from a retailer or not. As this gets more user penetration, if the prices at retailers are significantly different from online (taking into account things like sales tax and shipping), users will shift even more purchases online. So, this will force retailers to make their brick and mortar prices more competitive with online and should cause price parity across sources (of/when consumer penetration and usage is achieved). Could be the start of something big.

Local Shopping Coming To A Mobile Phone Near You

Women are more likely than men to be IYP users

I saw an interesting tool on another website today (it can be found at the link below). You activate this tool and it will go through your browser history, analyze the sites you've visited, and tell you if it thinks you're male or female. When I ran it, it said with 100% probability that I'm male (I am). But more interesting to me was the male/female ratios it displayed for various IYP/Local sites I've visited. Here they are:

• Yellowpages.com - 0.72 male/female (1.38 women per man on that site)
• Yelp - 0.77
• Yellowbook - 0.8
• ServiceMagic - 0.71
• DexKnows - 0.79
• Google - 0.98

As someone working in the local space online, this tells me that, across the board, 55-57% of our users are women. That's without any specific outreach effort to that group. Perhaps we should consider market more directly to them, or at least focus on the sites they're using, as they seem more predisposed to using us to start with.

Mike On Ads » Blog Archive » Using your browser URL history to estimate gender

Business Networking - The Future of Local Business Relationships?

Kudzu is a site for users to submit recommendations for their favorite businesses (like a Yelp or the like). They've just introduced something new, though, which is quite interesting: business recommendations. Basically, businesses can recommend other businesses who they think do a good job. So, for example, you may want to ask the general contractor you used once who a good plumber would be for a small job. That contractor may have recommended plumbers, roofers, etc through Kudzu. Good extension to the site if they can get the businesses to submit recommendations.

For me, this brings up the concept of business social networking, which has not really been done anywhere yet (that I know of). Not Linked-in style social networking, but the ability for businesses to network and meet/discuss issues with other businesses. Are you a plumber in Denver who wants advice from other plumbers across the country? Are you a restaurant in Denver who wants to discuss business with other Denver merchants? As the next generation, who has embraced social networking, become business owners, this concept will catch on, but as of now, noone has tried to do it yet. The best bets will be existing business directories like Kudzu or Yelp, or the IYPs, who have the customer relationships in place.

Kudzu Introduces Business Networking « Screenwerk

Top 10 IYP Search Categories (from the YPA)

So according to the YPA, here are the top 10:

1.  Restaurants
2.  Physicians & Surgeons
3.  Hotels
4.  Auto Repairing & Service
5.  Florists-Retail
6.  Auto Dealers-New & Used
7.  Dentists
8.  Auto Parts & Supplies - New & Used
9.  Beauty Salons (tie)
10. Hospitals (tie)

What does this all mean? Not sure, though it shows that people are using IYPs for the same searches they're using print for. To me, though, while IYPs will have a tough time maintaining their print shares in some of these categories, their online positions should be more defensible, if they go the right direction. Some of these categories, like Physicians and Dentists, are ones where users want significant data to help them make a decision. Right now, levels of data on IYPs are low, but if investments are made into collecting more data (like specialties for doctors, or types of insurance accepted, etc), they can become trusted sources for information on these categories.

Yellow Pages Association Names Top 10 Internet Yellow Pages Searches Reflecting How Consumers Are Using Local Search Sites

Canada's Yellow Pages Group (YPG) Entering the US Market

YPG from Canada is coming to the US, through an acquisition of Volt Information Services. It sounds like it's mostly for their technology/Internet assets, although they do have a bit of print business as well. From what I've heard, YPG is usually pretty aggressive and on the frontlines when it comes to Online, so it will be interesting to see how this manifests itself in the US.

Kelsey Group Blogs » YPG Enters US Market with Volt Deal